In chapter 6, we discussed in depth why betweenstudy heterogeneity is such an important issue when we are interpreting the results of our metaanalysis, and how we can explore sources of heterogeneity using outlier and influence analyses another source of betweenstudy heterogeneity making our effect size estimate less precise could be that there are slight. Ppt bayesian subgroup analysis powerpoint presentation. I was wondering if anyone can help with a subgroup. Computational model the researcher must always choose between a fixedeffect model and a randomeffects model. As stated in the stata survey manual, when the subpop option is used, the subpopulation is actually defined by the 0s false, which indicate those cases to be excluded from the subpopulation. Subgroup analyses can have different and distinct purposes, requiring specific design and. The strengths and weaknesses of this approach and new journal policies concerning the reporting of s. Implemented in the metan command in stata rfdist option not in revman yet but may be in future metaregression and subgroup analysismetaregression and subgroup analysis methods for investigating possible explanations of heterogeneity in a metaanalysis used to examine associations between studylevel. Subgroup effect can be defined as the difference in treatment effect across patient subgroups. Are there any differences between interaction and subgroup analysis. Create a free personal account to download free article pdfs, sign up for alerts, customize your interests, and more. Metaanalysis is a statistical technique for combining the results from. The twostage routine, ipdmetan, loops over a series of categories, fits the desired model to the data within each, and generates pooled effects, heterogeneity statistics etc, as appropriate. How can i compare regression coefficients across 3 or more groups.
This checklist is organised according to the design, analysis, and context of subgroup analysis. Although subgroup analyses in clinical trials may provide evidence for individualised medicine, their conduct and interpretation remain controversial. Subgroup analysis and other misuses of baseline data in. Evaluate study heterogeneity with subgroup analysis or metaregression. The analysis of subgroups is often used as a way to glean additional information from data sets. Adjusted significance levels for subgroup analyses in clinical trials. Data analysis with stata 12 tutorial university of texas. Does anyone have experience with subgroup plots in stata. See stata s full list of official meta analysis features.
The first metaanalysis showed a pooled a stata command to perform metaanalysis of when the fixed effects model is used in a subgroup metaanalysis. As of stata 16, stata has an official suite of meta analysis commands. Results are different from the ones obtained with your code, in that, creating interaction by hand, makes stata losing memory of the variables included in the. Was the subgroup analysis based on a rational indication.
However, the pvalue for the overall analysis is required to be below a certain level. A handson practical tutorial on performing metaanalysis. In meta analysis we are working with subgroups of studies rather than groups of subjects, but will follow essentially the same approach, using a variant of the ttest. Subgroup analyses in clinical trials are becoming increasingly important, because, especially in cancer research. Subgroup analysis and other mis uses of baseline data in clinical trials. It means that i have different datasets for each imputation.
One way is to run the same regression model separately for each group and test the differences between these two. Statacorp is a leading developer in statistical software, primarily through its flagship product stata. An updated collection from the stata journal, second edition, which brought together all the stata journal articles about the. How can i analyze a subpopulation of my survey data in stata. Chapter 7 subgroup analyses doing metaanalysis in r. Subgroup analyses constitute a fundamental step in the assessment of evidence from confirmatory phase iii clinical trials, where conclusions for the overall study population might not hold. Apr 21, 2020 statacorp is a leading developer in statistical software, primarily through its flagship product stata. Data analysis very strong very strong very strong strong. Cumulative subgroup analysis refers to a series of repeated pooling of subgroup effects after adding data from each of related trials chronologically.
How to work with a subgroup analysis pubmed central pmc. Manjula schou description produces various measures of expected treatment effect heterogeneity under an. Observations in each subgroup are weighted by the inverse of their conditional probabilities to belong to that subgroup, given a set of covariates. A set of routines for conducting twostage individual participant metaanalysis, aggregate summary data metaanalysis, and for creating highquality forest plots. In fact, i assumed you were using standard command in stata, therefore, the teffects command, since there is a faq recommendation to specify userwritten programs otherwise. Stata makes it easy to generate publicationquality, distinctly styled graphs, including descriptive graphs, regression fit graphs, etc. Mar 30, 2010 we restructured the checklist of items including the seven original and the four new criteria table 1. Subgroups analyses with multiple imputed data statalist. Stata keep using only complete cases to run the model so all imputed observations are not considered. See statas full list of official metaanalysis features stata users have also developed numerous excellent commands for performing metaanalyses. To conduct a metaanalysis in jasp, be sure to check our their guide. Analyzing the differential treatment effect in the reweighted sample helps isolating the difference due to the. Download limit exceeded you have exceeded your daily download allowance. It will also download brief descriptions of all userwritten commands published in the stata technical bulletin.
To do this analysis, we first make a dummy variable called age1 that is coded 1 if young age1, 0 otherwise, and age2 that is coded 1 if middle aged age2, 0 otherwise. I was wondering if anyone can help with a subgroup analysis. In particular, when studying interactions, the results of the regression analysis are more valid when complemented by additional exploratory analyses within relevant subgroups of patients or within strata defined by the covariates. When i performed a subgroup analysis on a catergorical moderator named moda with two levels. Statistical power for subgroup analyses and metaregression introduction in this chapter we address a number of issues that are relevant to both subgroup analyses analysis of variance and to metaregression. The aim of subgroup analysis is usually to assess whether the association of two variables differs depending on a third variable. Author links open overlay panel susan f assmann phd a prof stuart j pocock phd b laura e enos msc a linda e kasten ma a. The limitations of subgroup analyses are well establishedfalse positives due to multiple comparisons, false negatives due to inadequate power, and limited ability to inform individual treatment decisions because patients have multiple characteristics that vary simultaneously. Three simple rules to ensure reasonably credible subgroup. Used by professional researchers for more than 30 years, stata provides everything for. Determining whether or not there is heterogeneity in a treatment effectie, that a treatment works better in some subgroups than othersis fraught with statistical difficulties and has led to much misinterpretation. Remove this presentation flag as inappropriate i dont like this i like this remember as a favorite. My subgroup variables have been imputed i need to keep for example observation where subgroup1 and imputed for my model.
Subgroup analysis for regression discontinuity designs using inverse propensity score weighting acarrilrddsga. Hi, i want to compare the effect of one variable var1 on dependent variable across two subgroups e. I have looked at the coefficients in the white and african american subgroups, and found that they are not very close. Adjusted significance levels for subgroup analyses in. In order to use the results of a randomised trial, it is necessary to understand whether the overall observed benefit or harm applies to all individuals, or whether some subgroups receive more benefit or harm than others. Multivariate and subgroup analyses of a randomized, multinational, phase 3 trial of decitabine vs treatment choice of supportive care or cytarabine in older patients with newly diagnosed acute myeloid leukemia and poor or intermediaterisk cytogenetics. Package subgroup february 20, 2015 type package title methods for exploring treatment effect heterogeneity in subgroup analysis of clinical trials version 1. I am running subgroups analysis on multiple imputed data. The isat was initiated in 1997 and aimed to recruit 2500 patients to achieve a 90% power at the 1% level of significance to detect a 25% relative reduction in the proportion of patients dependent or dead at 1 year. Subgroup analysis using multiple linear regression. Stata 16 introduces a new suite of commands for performing metaanalysis. Jul 15, 20 using the collapse command to create aggregate data from individuallevel data using frequency weights.
The first meta analysis showed a pooled a stata command to perform meta analysis of when the fixed effects model is used in a subgroup meta analysis. Assess the impact of publication bias on results with trimandfill analysis. Subgroup analysis involves subdividing respondents in a survey into groups on the basis of demographic characteristics e. The metaanalysis function of jasp is based on the aforementioned metafor r package. Regarding the second suggestion, i have good reasons to believe that some interactions could be significant based on the subgroup analysis. Differences between interaction and subgroup analysis 08 jun 2015, 19.
Notes on subgroup analyses and metaregression meta. How can i compare regression coefficients across 3 or. Subgroup analysis is used for categorical covariates while metaregression is used for continuous covariates and categorical covariates. To conduct subgroup analyses using the mixedeffects model randomeffects model within subgroups, fixedeffects model between subgroups, you can use the subgroup. A short guide and a forest plot command ipdforest for onestage ipd meta analysis models with stata are partially addressed with subgroup analyses and. There are at least three ways to do subgroup analyses in r.
How to use a subgroup analysis with dr gordon guyatt abstract clinicians, when trying to apply trial results to patient care, need to individualize patient care and, potentially, manage patients based on results of subgroup analyses. In, the adjustment of the significance levels also incorporates the correlation between the test statistics of the overall and subgroup analysis. In metaanalysis we are working with subgroups of studies rather than groups of subjects, but will follow essentially the same approach, using a variant of the ttest. The adobe flash plugin is needed to view this content. Hi, all, i would like to compare predictors effects across different racialethnic groups, so i first ran a comprehensive model including all groups, and then used subpop. Jasp is a free, opensource program used to perform statistical analysis tests by using r packages. The most convenient way to install userwritten commands is from within stata. An updated collection from the stata journal, second edition, which brought. In chapter 6, we discussed in depth why betweenstudy heterogeneity is such an important issue when we are interpreting the results of our meta analysis, and how we can explore sources of heterogeneity using outlier and influence analyses.
So there is no evidence of a lack of statistical power, based on what youve suggested. The box shows the seven 1992 criteria, in a restructured checklist addressing design, analysis, and context of subgroup analyses in this paper. In this article, we apply bayess rule to determine the probability that a positive subgroup analysis is a true. This decision is commonly guided by a statistical test for interaction. Differences between interaction and subgroup analysis. Statistics in medicine reporting of subgroup analyses in. Ppt bayesian subgroup analysis powerpoint presentation free to download id.
Differences between interaction and subgroup analysis statalist. Use funnel plots and formal tests to explore publication bias and smallstudy effects. The general form to deal with by is to use it as a prefix. In this case, both the us analysis subgroup b and the europe analysis subgroup c are a subgroup of the whole population overall a, but neither is a. An example of subgroup analysis from the isat trial. To do something not on the entire dataset, but rather on subgroups, keyword by is used. The issue here is that if you perform one analysis you get a single. To numerically present this, you can ask stata for the skew and kurtosis statistics, including pvalues, as we did in section 3.
Meta analysis is a statistical technique for combining the results from several similar studies. Or, we could use analysis of variance to assess the variance among groups means relative to the variance within groups. Stata users have also developed numerous excellent commands for performing metaanalyses. Multivariate and subgroup analyses of a randomized. The importance of these criteria varies, but the relative weight that should be applied to each criterion remains uncertain. Non0 values are included in the analysis, except for missing values, which are excluded from the analysis.
Subgroup analyses can have different and distinct purposes, requiring specific design and analysis solutions. Feb 06, 2014 multivariate and subgroup analyses of a randomized, multinational, phase 3 trial of decitabine vs treatment choice of supportive care or cytarabine in older patients with newly diagnosed acute myeloid leukemia and poor or intermediaterisk cytogenetics. May 18, 2015 i am running subgroups analysis on multiple imputed data. For instance, investigators of a study testing the effect of an intervention variable 1 on preventing heart attacks variable 2 might be interested in whether the effect varies by smoking status variable 3. I was wondering if anyone can help with a subgroup analysis in stata. As of stata 16, stata has an official suite of metaanalysis commands. Inferences about subgroup effects are stronger, if, at the design stage, the comparison is made within rather than between studies, the subgroup hypothesis is specified a priori, and a small number.
Stata is a complete, integrated statistical package that provides everything for data analysis from data management to basic analysis and advanced analysis. Those relating to metaanalysis can be displayed by typing search meta. It is most useful for data transformations, but of course it may also be used to do analyses by subgroups. Using the collapse command to create aggregate data from individuallevel data using frequency weights. Second, the tapply function can be used to perform analyses across a set of subgroups in a. A short guide and a forest plot command ipdforest for onestage ipd metaanalysis models with stata are partially addressed with subgroup analyses and.
Baseline data collected on each patient at randomisation in controlled clinical trials can be used to describe the population of patients, to assess comparability of treatment groups, to achieve balanced randomisation, to adjust treatment comparisons for prognostic factors, and to undertake subgroup analyses. First and i think easiest, we can use a select statement to restrict an analysis to a subgroup of subjects. In the following sections we provide an example of fixed and random effects metaanalysis using the metan command. This is a guide on how to conduct metaanalyses in r. Notes on subgroup analyses and metaregression metaanalysis.
880 966 147 139 469 1072 1040 616 110 485 1175 420 1135 121 999 216 1269 1490 406 880 666 193 526 56 1281 707 635 849 93 1049 819